Sample Menu


Pig Wings

We start with big, meaty St. Louis cut ribs, smoke them for 3-4 hours, then crisp them up in the fryer. Tossed with sauce or rub of your choice. We always knew they could fly. 5 ($12) / 10 ($23) / 15 ($34) (sauces / rubs can split in 5s)

Smoked Chicken Wings

Created by a Buffalo boy and self-proclaimed “wing snob,” our wings are slow-smoked and finished in the fryer for the crispiest, tastiest wing around. Our wings are always served “crispy” and extra saucy with housemade bleu cheese dressing, carrots, and celery. 10 ($11) / 20 ($21) / 30 ($31) / 50 ($51)


Mild, Medium, Hot, XXX Hot House BBQ, Hot BBQ, Carolina BBQ, Hoisin BBQ, Chipotle Honey Mustard, Ivory BBQ, Red Eye BBQ, Chipotle honey mustard, Original Hot Sauce, Sweet & Sour, Nashville Hot

Dry Rubs

Nickel’s BBQ Rub,
Garlic Parmesan,
Hot Cajun

Mixes (+$1)

Buffalo Garlic Parmesan (hot, medium, or mild)

Crazy (ivory, garlic parm, hot drizzle)

Chipotle Honey Ranch (chipotle honey mustard & ranch rub)

Ragin’ Cajun (ivory Bbq, cajun rub, green onion)

spicy sweet & Sour (medium, sweet & sour, splash xxx)

OG (house bbq & everything rub)

Fried Jalapeños

Spicy pickled jalapeños, lightly floured and fried until crispy. Served with our housemade buttermilk ranch. Great with any of our BBQ sauces. $9

Pulled Pork Nachos

House-fried tortilla chips topped with our classic pulled pork, jalapeño peppadew cheese sauce, pico de gallo, dry rub sour cream, jalapeños, and our Original Hot Sauce. Because you’ve earned it, add bacon for $3. $12

Onion Rings

Big hand-cut rings, battered in our zesty house-made beer batter, golden fried. Ranch to dip. $10


Thick-cut dill chips, beer battered and fried. Served with house bleu cheese to dip. $10

 Loaded Tots


Chx Bacon Ranch

Tots tossed with our homemade ranch dry rub and topped with pulled chicken, bacon, and cheddar. With ranch and chipotle honey mustard.
$12 / 14

Loaded Potato

Crispy tots with melted local cheddar, bacon, green onion, dry rub sour cream, and ranch. Like a loaded baked potato.
$11 / 13

Nacho Tots

Crispy fried tots, jalapeño peppadew cheese sauce, pico de gallo, dry rub sour cream, pickled jalapeños, Original Hot Sauce.
$10 / 12

Buffalo Chicken

seasoned with our signature ranch rub, smoked chicken, bleu and cheddar cheese, medium wing sauce. Celery side car. Bleu dressing.
$12 / 14


Made to order. Local roll. Served with choice of one side. 


Classic Pulled Pork

Tender, slow-smoked pork shoulder. Piled high and served on a fresh baked roll. Unsauced. $12

The Cuban

Our pulled pork with Carolina BBQ, double smoked bacon, dill pickle, Swiss cheese. $14

Mac Attack

Nickel’s classic pulled pork topped with our famous jalapeño peppadew mac and cheese and Original Hot Sauce. $15


Polish style! Schrader farms smoked kielbasa, split & charbroiled w/ kraut, house 1000 island, swiss sauce. $13

Classic Brisket

Our tender, slow-smoked brisket, dipped in au jus and piled onto a white roll. No sauce, no veggies, no BS. $13

Brisket on Weck

Au jus dipped smoked brisket, spicy prepared horseradish, caraway seeds, chunky salt. Go Bills. $14

BBB (Three B)

Brisket, bacon, bleu. Our brisket sandwich topped with crumbled bleu cheese and local double-smoked bacon. $15

turkey ranch

hot smoked turkey, bacon, fresh greens, tomato, ranch,chipotle honey mustard. $14

Carolina Pulled Pork

Slow smoked pulled pork, house sweet ‘n’ creamy slaw, Carolina sauce. $13

Buffalo Pulled Pork

Slow smoked pulled pork, house sweet ‘n’ creamy slaw, medium Buffalo sauce, bleu cheese. $13

Brisket Burger

Not a “burger,” really. Our tender brisket topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese sauce. $14

Triple Hog

A classic Nickel’s presentation. Split charbroiled kielbasa, pulled pork, and bacon. $15

BBQ Salads

Meal-sized salads. Add bacon (or more bacon) for $3.

Southwest Pork

Pulled pork, greens, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese, black beans, roasted corn, dry rub sour cream, jalapeños, green onion, and a few tortilla chips. $16


chopped turkey, bacon, tomato, onion, roasted corn, black beans, cucumber, fresh greens & tots. Dressed with ranch, drizzled w/ house bbq. $16 Meatless (no meat, extra veg) $13

Sweet Turkey

Greens, smoked turkey (cold), dried cranberries, bleu cheese crumbles, red onion. Topped with sweet potato fries. Side of vinaigrette. Give thanks! $16

Ribs • Chicken • Combos • Plates

Combos served with cornbread and any 2 sides. Add 5 wings for $5. 


Nickel’s Split BBQ

Feeds a small army of at least 2 - it’s everything! Pulled pork, brisket, kielbasa, smoked turkey, 1/4 chicken, 1/4 rack, 5 wings, 3 pig wings. 2 sides and cornbread. $61


Rubbed and slow smoked -- these are big, meaty St. Louis spare ribs. 1/2 Rack $22 Full Rack $34

Ribs ‘n’ Chicken

Best of both worlds. 1/2 rack, 1/4 chicken $30 1/2 chicken, 1/4 rack $29 1/4 chicken, 1/4 rack $22

BBQ Mess Plate

Shout out to our friend’s in the ROC (Nickel’s version of Rochester’s Garbage Plate). Tots and mac salad, topped with the meat of your choice and smothered with chili, cheddar, and onions. Bread on the side. A big, glorious mess (only served together). $18


1/2 chicken. Marinated for 24 hours in Nickel’s Chicken Sauce, slow smoked, and finished on the charbroiler. We recommend plenty of Chicken Sauce to dip and drench. With 2 sides and cornbread. $20




The Original Combo $15
(pulled pork)

Choose 1 $16
(brisket, sausage, or turkey)

Choose 2 $21
(pulled pork, brisket, kielbasa, or turkey)

Choose 3 $26
(pulled pork, brisket, kielbasa, or turkey)

Wing Combo $11/17
(5/10 wings)

Pig Wing Combo $18
(5 pig wings)

Add 1/4 rack for $10
Add 1/4 chicken for $9
Add 5 wings for $6
Add 3 pig wings for $7.50


Regular Sides

mac salad • curly fries • tots • baked beans • southern greens • grilled corn on the cob • coleslaw • chili • tomato cuke salad

Premium Sides (+$1)

sweet potato fries • crazy corn • side green salad • jalapeño peppadew mac and cheese

All sides are made in-house from original recipes. Pricing for sides alone: $3.50 each ($4.50 premium)